ABSTRACT The aim of this study was to replicate the study conducted by Chappette and Barth (2016) on the effects of model physical attractiveness and gender congruence on profile likability. In addition, the aim of the study was also to examine the effects of age and gender congruence on the assessment of profile likability and differences in the desire for a long-term relationship in view of age and profile congruence. The research was conducted online and 911 participants (604 women and 307 men) with an average age of 26.88 years (SD = 6.79) evaluated 4 profiles of the gender that attracted them. The effect of physical attractiveness on the profile likability was found in men but not in women, while the opposite was found for the profile congruence effect on the assessment of the profile likability. Women preferred non-congruent profiles, while physical attractiveness had no effect on the assessment of profile likability. Men, on the other hand, rated physically above-average attractive models more positively, while the congruence of gender roles was not important to them in assessing profile likability. No significant interaction of physical attractiveness and gender congruence was obtained on the assessment of profile likability. Differences in the congruence of profiles on the desire to achieve a long-term relationship were found only in women. Women are more interested in having long-term relationships with non-congruent profiles, that is with feminine men. Differences in the congruence of profiles on the assessment of the desire to achieve a long-term relationship by age were found only in the third age group for above-average attractive models, and in the second for average attractive models. Both age groups showed a greater desire to achieve a long-term relationship with gender non-congruent profiles. These findings are not completely in accordance with the research conducted by Chappetta and Barth (2016). This suggests that the relationship between attractiveness, gender congruence, age and the desire for a long-term relationship is more complex and should be further investigated.